#47
Dying in the Sun
By Jon de Burgh Miller
I was a little apprehensive about this one, what with Jon de Burgh Miller’s previous Doctor Who book (or at least Who-adjacent) being Twilight Of The Gods, the final Bernice Summerfield novel co-written with Mark Clapham. Circumstances meant that Twilight was written in a hurry and to my mind it showed: reliant on clichés and not convincing in its character writing, it was comfortably the worst Benny book.
Dying In The Sun also had a notable publishing journey, but at least not a rushed one. It was pitched as an Eighth Doctor “stuck on Earth” novel, then retooled for the Seventh Doctor and Ace, then retooled again for the Second Doctor, Ben and Polly. (Credit: I, Who.) This time however the book’s behind-the-scenes tribulations are not especially apparent.
It’s set in Hollywood circa 1947, and sounds like it: lines like “It was the City of Angels, and the angels were screaming” have a certain Humphrey Bogart charm to them, or cheese, depending on your persuasion. I don’t know if Miller or Clapham was responsible for the action movie bent of their last book, but this one’s somewhat hokey setting allows for that sort of thing to come off more naturally, or at least more of a piece with the surroundings. The whole novel doesn’t sound like it’s narrated by a moody gumshoe – more’s the pity – but it has a certain earnestness that might not have worked in a less tacky time and place. I felt comfortable enough with lines like “For a moment, a very short moment, Chate thought he could see sadness in her eyes, like she’d caught a fleeting glimpse of a past that was too painful to bear.” I don’t know if Miller had a tongue in cheek writing that, but it works.
Of the three Doctor/companion combos in the novel’s DNA I’d say Miller landed on the right one, with Ben and Polly being quite close to this time period, a couple of cool kids and very much the children of these movies. It’s unusual to find this TARDIS team enjoying a long layover somewhere, what with this Doctor having no control over his travels and most of those being base-under-siege horror, but it makes sense that they’d want to stick around and enjoy themselves when they’re close-ish to their own era. Polly has a natural glamour that fits well in Hollywood – numerous people tell her that she could be a movie star, and that doesn’t sound like a stretch – while Ben sounds as exasperated as ever. (He seems a hard one to write for but if you get that right, you’re golden.) Finally, the shabbiest Doctor of all provides a delightful contrast against the glamour of Hollywood. His avuncular friendliness, even when accused of murder, fits just right for the character. It’s perhaps a bit odd that he wants to renew a pre-existing friendship with a Hollywood producer – where he can’t pilot the TARDIS it seems unlikely that he’d know somebody – but that might be a casualty of the novel’s earlier versions. You wouldn’t blink if this was McCoy.
The plot is also well integrated into the setting. A new movie is coming out (called Dying In The Sun, naturally) and it’s causing some unusual reactions. The special effects seem impossibly good for the era, and they even seem to change from one screening to another. The stars associated with it have a supernatural glow to them, which has begun to proliferate through the Hollywood ranks. A local organisation has blossomed into a full-blown cult, its members becoming one with a strange microscopic race of aliens that only want to enhance our specialness and share it through movies. The Doctor of course understands that this will mean slavery for the human race.
It’s not hard to decipher the satirical elements of Miller’s Hollywood, with its unnatural allure and powerful cabals in the shadows. The “Selyoids” (the name is a deliberate joke, it’s not that cheesy) allow for a lot of sci-fi fun and games however, with film reels manipulated by them, a glamour added to those who join with them, zombies who are fully controlled by them, enormous projections powered by them and occasional monsters manifested by them right out of the movies. The downside is that, as well as being a little all over the place conceptually, they are a disembodied force – something the characters talk about rather than to, which leads to a bit too much “as you know, Bob” near the end. The Doctor and co debate the morality of the Selyoids living symbiotically with humankind but it feels like they can’t do that in good faith while a) the people debating it are not themselves and b) the Selyoids don’t specifically get a vote. Polly, by this point drinking the proverbial Kool Aid, talks about how wonderful it is to join with them, but that doesn’t really come from an emotional place; we just recognise that it’s cool when people think you’re pretty and want your autograph. (We skip the rather more convincing part where Selyoids can cure all injuries and presumably all illnesses.) Again, it’s satire, and not a very deep one. Hollywood ain’t that deep either, I’m sure.
There isn’t a lot of depth elsewhere in the novel. There’s a murder mystery (the Doctor’s producer friend) where curiously we skip the actual event – it would surely have been worth showing, since the Doctor was present to some extent. There’s a murder suspect, mob enforcer Rob Chate, who we’re supposed to sympathise with but who does actually commit a murder shortly afterwards. (Self defence.) Towards the end of the novel, with practically everyone now under the Selyoid influence, it becomes difficult to differentiate Chate from Detective Fletcher, the hard-boiled investigator who thinks the Doctor dunit. The family history between Chate and police chief Wallis is important but a little too histrionic to make any real impact – it just sounds like a cheesy movie twist, which admittedly might be the point. The book mostly just tumbles along once the Doctor becomes fascinated by the movie at the centre of things, with no real impetus on solving the initial mystery – and, as established, not much of a pronounced alien presence for him to rally against.
Dying In The Sun really does tumble along though. Miller keeps a good pace and the setting is quite colourful, even though a few of its ideas have been done before. (Creatures stepping out of movies, see: Theatre Of War. Symbiotic alien invasions, see: how long have you got?) I’ve got a lot of time for books where it’s clear what’s going on and the author creates some memorable imagery. And, as it seems mandatory to point out based on other reviews for it, there are no deliberate continuity refs here: the TARDIS isn’t mentioned, no previous adventures are alluded to, it’s just three travellers wrapped up in a sci-fi adventure. So it’s a good one to pick up at random, which funnily enough is the thing the EDAs have been striving towards. When order is at last restored, Dying In The Sun: The Movie becomes just another day at the pictures. Miller’s book doesn’t aspire to a whole lot more than that, but it’ll kill time just as well.
6/10