#61
The Colony Of Lies
By Colin Brake
Let’s get this nitpick out of the way first: do we need the “The”? “Colony Of Lies” sounds fine. “The Colony Of Lies” sounds like it has a floating extra syllable. There are examples where this works, or at least isn’t picked on, like The Web Of Fear and The Mind Of Evil. I’m not sure why it doesn’t work here — is it just places? It would work with a Target-style prefix: Doctor Who and the Colony Of Lies has a quaint, fun ring to it, like Indiana Jones and the Temple Of Doom. But when people abbreviate that one it’s always just, Temple Of Doom.
Anyway, this is the second novel from Colin Brake, whose Escape Velocity delivered us Anji Kapoor and resolved a plot arc but otherwise didn’t set the world alight. The Colony Of Lies (it just doesn’t sound right!) is a more assured and less messy effort, although some unfortunate habits persist.
It begins with a fun framing device. The Seventh Doctor and Ace visit a mind-boggling museum that engages Ace’s imagination over an old human colony on Axista Four. Apparently the people there were committed to Back To Basics, a philosophy/lifestyle of reduced technology that more or less replicated the American West. The Doctor clearly remembers visiting it and promptly tells Ace that they’re not going to bother. Meanwhile he reads his diary on the matter. We then cut back to the colony just before the Second Doctor, Jamie and Zoe arrive. (I like that this is a reversal of Independence Day — a Seventh Doctor novel that begins with a Second Doctor cameo. Like the Peter Darvill-Evans book, the cameo ends up having relevance to the story.)
The colony mostly consists of a town called Plymouth Hope, a ramshackle place in the shadow of their crashed hundred-year-old spaceship. The populace has split into two factions: Loyalists who really like Back To Basics and Realists who fancy a bit more technology in their lives. This has the potential to be the central conflict of the book, especially when the town’s de facto sheriff sees his grandson run off to join to the Realists one night; stakes seem high right away when a simple meeting of the two groups erupts into a deadly firefight. But there are many more conflicts to come and this one just doesn’t rate very highly. This is a pity as it robs us of some world-building. We don’t get much into what life is like in the more rustic Plymouth Hope, nor how things differ for the Realists; it all feels suitably like a space Western whether you’ve got a horse or a speeder to go about in. The iconography just needed a bit more work to be different, especially after (as Brake wryly notes in his Acknowledgements) Dale Smith wrote a Doctor Who Western not long before this. (On the other hand, a lack of difference between groups is a theme in this one, so maybe this is deliberate? Hmm.)
My main issue with Escape Velocity was the way it delivered information (and ultimately, drama), and that somewhat carries over into The Colony Of Lies. The prose is pleasantly readable and often adopts a child-friendly tone to tell us things on the sly: “What Hali and her companions didn’t know was that, for once, the colony ship was not entirely devoid of life.” / “As the Doctor and Zoe made their way towards the light, neither of them was aware that a security system had been triggered by their travelling companion.” / “In fact, hundreds of kilometres above the surface of the planet, something was happening that perfectly demonstrated the Doctor’s point.” This works quite well to draw you in, but sometimes it snowballs into revealing actual significant plot details, which quite simply deserved their own moment. In particular “With their limited numbers, surprise was one of the greatest weapons in their arsenal. And they would need it if they were going to have their revenge on the humans for the unprovoked attack that had destroyed their fledgling settlement” is absolutely thrown away in third person prose — although more information is added later that contextualises it.
The Colony Of Lies loves information. It feels a bit silly to say that a story is all about characters finding things out — they all do that! — but this one really does fall into a pattern of action scene, action scene, terrible secret, repeat, which has the effect of suggesting that they’d all be better off waiting for a group email at the end. (Indeed, the Doctor carries around Chekhov’s Plot Twist for half the book, fruitlessly looking for a USB port that will accept and open it. He finds one when it is expedient to do so, which is a bit of a cheek.)
These moments at least carry some dramatic weight — particularly the one where Zoe finds something out via a virtual reality mind-meld with a crashing spaceship, I mean that sure beats reading about it — but sometimes even they fall flat, such as that final revelation (no spoilers) which fundamentally reframes an entire group and they all just accept this on the spot. Where is the dissent? A whole book spent getting argy with their neighbours and then one bit of evidence clears it all away? It’s not the only opportunity for drama that’s curiously muted here, with others including that estranged grandfather and grandson (the granddad literally forgets that he ran away for some of it) and two women in love with the same man (that was ages ago so it’s fine now/just random colour). Like the Loyalist/Realist debate, apart from one firefight things tend to fizzle out.
Away from the big reveals the overall info-delivery can feel like busywork. Characters frequently restate the status quo, such as what Back To Basics is all about, or do the exact opposite where the prose (helpfully?) summarises their summaries for us. I think this was also a thing in Escape Velocity. These three examples appear in quick succession: “Hali and Max explained to Zoe about the alien bunker he had discovered.” / “Zoe explained about the refugee crisis and the huge number of new colonists that would shortly be arriving on Axista Four.” / “Jamie could see that Zoe was confused and explained that Billy Joe’s Grandpa was the sheriff.” If what they’re saying is too redundant for our ears, can they not just talk about something else, or else get all their information in clumps? Fiction-in-having-plot-description shocker, I know, but I think it’s notable that most books don’t have this many summarised conferences along the way.
I’m coming down on the negative side so far, and before I rebalance the scales a bit here’s one more: there are some weird errors/malapropisms that maybe shouldn’t be a thing any more where these books had gone bi-monthly and there was presumably more time to edit them. “He’d become the city’s solo problem child.” Should be “sole.” “Tam’s impromptu speech managed to illicit some cheers.” Elicit. “No, I’m nae from Earth Gov. Whatever that it.” Is. “He found Tam and Freedom looking at him with concerned expressions.” Dee, not Tam, is in this scene.
But despite my objections, some of which are admittedly nitpicks, I found things to like here. For all my annoyance with the world-building of Back To Basics — the schism at the heart of which has been fodder for countless Star Trek episodes, and probably some Doctor Who — the book eventually reframes it as a loose satire on organised religion, complete with built-in hypocrisy. That altogether shaky difference of opinion can be argued as the point, if you’re so inclined. Despite the plot focusing on conflict with two “Western” groups, some angry aliens and shady people from Earth who annoy just about everyone else, it ultimately moves towards peace as a guiding principle, halting a bloodbath and pre-empting some equally grim retribution — all of which feels deliberately counter to, and therefore in conversation with the Westerns that inspired it. (Conversely I’m not entirely sure that Brake knows what to do with the idea of 80,000 refugees from the Dalek wars needing to live here — the idea seems to be acceptable or bad depending on what mood people are in.)
There’s also an apparent effort to incorporate female characters, which is one of those things you probably shouldn’t need to call out, but nonetheless it’s rare to find them in the majority. While at times I found that the overall helpfulness of Dee, Hali, Veena and Kirann blurred them together a bit as characters, I appreciated that they all had an impact and each had their own little peccadillos. The male characters tend to be less defined, like the captain of the Earth ship and the shadowy Earth administrator behind him, which probably wasn’t by design but all the same does sort of foreground the women.
The regulars are quite well done, with the Doctor bumbling about and generally trusting Jamie to get into scrapes, and Zoe making frequent use of her previously established eidetic memory. (Jamie is somewhat of a clod at points, though perhaps he’s just annoyed by the too-frequent, deliberately ignorant references to his “skirt”.) I’m undecided on the Seventh Doctor in this: his involvement certainly falls under the (question mark) umbrella of “manipulator”, with interactions before the Second Doctor arrives and then some psychically during these events, but there isn’t much stated reasoning for him to push the boat out as much as he does here. It’s gently suggested that he’s the New Adventures Doctor (white linen suit; a character says “crukking”) so perhaps it’s meant to be a response to something.
It moves at a decent lick. I read it in two sittings. There’s perhaps too much “action scene followed by hospitalisation,” with particular emphasis on ping-ponging back and forth to a ship in orbit, but Brake certainly keeps the pace up by doing that. I had a decent time with The Colony Of Lies, despite it being a little muted and uncertain in places. It generally feels like Brake is a novel or two away from really killing it — Steve Cole also took a while — but overall you can see why the Seventh Doctor would put his feet up and read about it.
6/10