#39
Original Sin
By Andy Lane
Well that was a stone cold
belter, wasn’t it?
Forgive the haste. Sometimes I like to build up to that – since
it’s a rare-ish occurrence, maybe it’s worth a bit of ceremony – but it can be
such a relief to sit back and enjoy reading that I just want to get on with it. So: yep.
Original Sin is One Of The
Good Ones. Thanks for reading!
Perhaps it’s not surprising, as Andy
Lane is hardly new to all this. There’s
a confident spring in his step that no doubt comes with experience. Yes, there’s a Prologue – it’s the law! – but
you can forget any wiffly metaphysical guff.
Lane begins breathlessly with the tail-end of another adventure, one
that leads directly into Original Sin. I love stories that forgo the obvious “Arrive,
ask questions, investigate” rigmarole, and this is a great way to circumvent
it.
The prologue also displays some of
the book’s overall strengths, things it generally shares with Lucifer Rising
(co-written by Lane): world building and plot, working together. Writers often get bogged down in one or the
other, and both create their own challenges all by themselves. The Menagerie came up with an interesting
setting filled with lots of different life forms, but it couldn’t quite carve
them out from each other or make them live. Original
Sin introduces us right away to the Hith, a lizard-like species with
unusually poetic names like Homeless Forsaken Betrayed And Alone, a permanent
reminder to other species of what happened to them. This one has been shot, and whispers
(Hitchcock-style) a gloomy pronouncement to Bernice about the fate of Earth. Right away we’ve got an unusual species (whom
we’ll see a lot more of) and something pressing to attend to on Earth. Both these things get progressively more
interesting.
The Earth Empire is prospering,
but that really depends what species you are.
Lane takes a pessimistic (though perhaps not Transit pessimistic) view
of our future, where humans have “offered assistance” to countless planets
including Hithis, so in other words taken over, turfed them out and stolen
their technology. A current of
xenophobia runs through humanity, even among the “nice” ones, as they regard
displaced aliens (e.g. the Hith) as lowly or disgusting. A Hith named Powerless Friendless allows us
to explore this idea further, particularly as he lives in the Undertown. Earth is divided into the prosperous and
everyone else, which in itself isn’t a very original concept, but it mixes with
Lane’s climate of speciesism to make something new. The humans, ever self-loathing, have taken to
“body beppling”: a means of transforming into anything they can think of, which
is all the cosmetic rage. This adds yet
another dimension to the strange, sad cloud of conflict that surrounds this
story, all of which explodes because of the plot, which involves a series of
random and unprovoked murders that snowball into riots. There it is again: a rich seam of
world-building which you could almost take for granted, since it’s colourful
and interesting, only the plot then finds a use for all of it.
Admittedly it’s a simple-ish
plot, but there’s nothing wrong with that so long as it’s well executed. A good murder mystery can be as satisfyingly
simple or complicated as you make it, and the trail of death is not just
unpleasantly memorable (as Lane must find new ways for people to dispose of
each other) but also poignant, as the deaths have consequences, both personal
and on a larger scale. We do not,
admittedly, see the full effect of the Earth Empire tearing itself to pieces – though
there are newscasts that give a flavour of it at the start of each chapter –
but this is ultimately one story that impacts on those wider issues, and it
makes sense to keep our focus there.
Focus is another of those things that shouldn’t be taken for granted.
Speaking of personal consequences,
then: Powerless Friendless is as cheery as his name suggests, but we have no
difficulty in getting inside his slug-like skin, or feeling the scorn of almost
everyone around him. Perhaps more
familiar to passing readers are a couple of law-enforcing Adjudicators named
Chris and Roz (or in the latter case, Forrester) who are not only investigating
the murders, but growing more aware of deception in their peers. Forrester (I don’t really feel right calling
her Roz – mind you, I’m still
sticking with “Bernice” over “Benny”, as I don’t like the automatic
masculinisation of companion names) is fighting her own personal battles as she
copes with a new partner, having lost her previous one and mentor in unhappy
circumstances. Again, this is not brand
new territory – you can see Lane’s keenness for pop culture in his references,
which go beyond Doctor Who into
adamantium and planets named Riggs and Murtaugh! – but it’s executed cleverly,
drip-feeding us information over the course of the book. Forrester runs the risk of being a tough,
no-nonsense cliché, but there’s enough self-loathing (to do with her privileged
upbringing) and begrudging humour to make her more. Her long-suffering dialogue with the
enthusiastic and adorable Chris is worth the price of admission. “Hey!”
said Cwej suddenly. Bernice turned back
to face him and Forrester. “I've got an
idea!” “Treat it gently,” Forrester
murmured, “it's in a strange place.”
She’ll fit right in with Bernice.
I’ll wait and see with Chris: he’s sweet and funny, but he’s got “write
as a moron” written all over him. The
joke about his surname, which looks like Cwej but should be pronounced Shvey
but he sticks with Cwej because it’s easier for everyone, takes so long to explain that it isn’t particularly funny.
Surprisingly, for a story gagging
to show off world-shaking ideas and grisly murders, it’s also got character
development for the regulars. Bernice,
mostly in terms of sympathy. There are
some clever reflections on her life with the Doctor, and how she constantly
wants to A) get back in the TARDIS and B) get out of the damn thing, which make
us aware that for a box that’s bigger on the inside, it’s still a box. In the main though, she’s mostly there to
field the plight of Homeless Forsaken (whose death starts it all) and Powerless
Friendless, to whom she obviously feels an obligation. There’s still plenty of delightful Bernice
stuff, and her scenes with the Doctor (until, inevitably, they take separate
paths) only make me more confident that these two belong together, and any
writer not revelling in that is on the wrong bus.
Much more thoughtful, and perhaps
more disturbing, is what this says about the Doctor. You might not expect another book to delve
into his thoughts straight after Human Nature, which was surely the definitive book
on the subject. But Original Sin shows there’s still plenty to needle at. The Doctor, for all his whimsy and heroism,
is quick to scoop out the brain of a dead man to examine the cause of his
insanity. In his fearful moments, which
the plot provides in abundance and without cheating, he thinks darkly of the
Valeyard and when he’s close to death, his eighth incarnation “waiting to take over”. It’s his conversations with a psychopath,
Professor Pryce, that provide the most sobering look: Pryce believes there is
no truly solid argument against murder other than we do not want to be
murdered, and realising that people can easily condemn and rationalise murder
in the same breath, the Doctor sees sense in that. He must prevent it simply because it’s what
he believes is right. He applies the
same logic to time travel nearer the end, when another villain holds a mirror
up to him; he is Time’s Champion for no particular reason, it’s just his lot. It can be cool to mythologise the Doctor, but
it’s refreshing to peel it back and show a guy just doing what he can, and must.
If you don’t know who the villain
is lurking in Original Sin, well done;
I wasn’t able to avoid it. Fortunately,
knowing does not take much away from the book, although it’s surely more fun not to know. There is simply reams of other stuff to
enjoy, and plenty of story to follow, leaving the late reveal of [redacted]
more a treat than a vital ingredient.
The handling of said character (oh, all right, it’s wee Jimmy Krankie)
is relished and doesn’t trample on the previous stuff, although a good deal of
retcon is involved, turning them into a shadowy menace behind numerous other
stories as well. If you are a fan of
their earlier appearance(s), I doubt you’ll be disappointed. If you do know it’s them, be aware it’s not
the all-singing, all-dancing Wee Jimmy Krankie Show as the reveal is a last-act
thing.
On top of all the other
spectacular (and yet focused, plot-driven) stuff going on, this is of course an
introduction for new companions. The
Doctor pats the TARDIS and says it’ll be just like old times. I have no idea how this will affect the
dynamic, but they’re interesting and fun, and it doesn’t appear they’ll get in
Bernice’s way, so I’m all for it. Original Sin doesn’t read like a
typical introductory story, with the twosome barely meeting the Doctor
throughout, but there’s a lot to be said for doing things differently. Whether or not they were always intended to
depart in the TARDIS, they arrive in a rich story you’re likely to read
compulsively. It’s not as dazzlingly
unusual as something like Human Nature, but what it does, it does in relentless style.
8/10
This is an amazing novel! Exciting, humourous, cleverly plotted, full of rich details about future earth, and full of living, interesting characters. I really enjoyed the inner monologues and bizarre culture of the lonesome Hiths: who could not like an alien who calls himself Homeless Forsaken Betrayed And Alone out a grievance against the evil Terran empire? (All of this corrupt empire stuff in the New Adventures makes me wonder what the Great and Bountiful Human Empire of nuwho is about.)
ReplyDeleteThe seventh Doctor is written more like Sylvester McCoy in this one, which is always a good thing. Bernice is funny and sassy as usual. The comedic policeman duo of Roz and Cwej both contribute to the rollicking plot and to the exposition of their crazy world. I am not sure that the final villain was necessary: the plot seemed to have a good rationale for doomsday without him, and I would have preferred to see the come-uppance of the evil empress than a returning old villain (although he was nonetheless enjoyable and well integrated into the story).
As usual for space opera, the technobabble and pseudoscience are dreamy and silly. Something about an imaginary particle which exists naturally in hyperspace, enabling easy hyperspace travel but simultaneously driving humans (but not aliens?) insane from its hyperspacey radiation. At least this stuff has a sort of internal logic and remains consistent throughout the novel. Like most technobabble however, it is immediately and permanently forgotten and ignored by every subsequent writer in the books, comics and television.
This book also contains more than its fair share of horror and graphic violence, but perhaps because it logically follows from the plot of magically induced planet-wide insanity, I easily forgave it.
10/10 Right up there with Exodus.
Fair enough! I loved it, but - nitpicker that I am - I do think the plot's slight messiness towards the end keeps it from a perfect score. Mind you, ratings are a mine-field for me.
DeleteFWIW, I rate it the same as Exodus, and I would highly recommend both. Having read further afield (currently on book #60, so the next 5 shouldn't be long), I'm really enjoying how Original Sin has become a sort of hub. Novels often reference the future, starting from here.
P.S. I didn't imagine the Hith as a "lizard-like species", more of a shellless snail-like species. Books are like that. And roleplaying games which use theatre of the imagination.
ReplyDeleteAlso fair enough. Perhaps an illustration might have helped, but that might also have detracted from the fun. (I'm not hugely fond of the cover. They couldn't find anything more iconic to look at?)
Delete