#40
Sky Pirates!
By Dave Stone
Oh no, not Dave Stone. In the modest annals of New Adventures discussion, no author is discussed with as many awkward sidelong glances or nervous fidgets as this one. To read the reviews you’d think he was a one-man marmite factory, a purveyor of books so bizarre they’re not so much “written down” as “mashed into existence with fists dabbed haphazardly in hundreds and thousands and mud”.
As it happens I’ve felt like that
for years: my first experience of a New Adventure (and possibly my first Doctor Who book) was a Dave Stone. I’ve owned Death And Diplomacy for decades
(plural – Jesus!), and I dimly remember the bewilderment of trying to read
it. Just what the hell is this,
anyway? Who are those people on the
cover? Where are the Daleks? I was still working through all of David J
Howe’s non-fiction books at the time and oh, dear lord, those endless lists of
things from Doctor Who… bliss! I really enjoyed learning about it all and,
as you might have guessed, wasn’t so hot on going outside and doing things, so
Dave Stone’s solitary New Adventure, with its somewhat adult humour and reams
of weird stuff made absolutely no
sense to me. It still might not when I
get to it later. Fingers crossed.
But before all that, there’s Sky Pirates! And oh boy.
I’m almost grateful for all the hushed, couched “Careful, now”s from
kind fellow readers, as none of that prepared me for such a good book. Stand down red alert! Sky
Pirates! is properly good and fun and written in totally comprehensible
words! Well, mostly. But if anything, it’s better written than
most of the books in the range.
Yes, it’s a bit bizarre at times,
if not constantly. There’s whimsy
encrusted in its DNA. You don’t get
“Chapter One”, you get “The First Chapter”; you don’t get song lyrics at the
start of each section, you get bad jokes (mostly courtesy of Bernice
Summerfield); the narrator is someone transcribing it long after the fact,
though they keep a merciful enough distance to be both amusing in their own
right and a barely noticeable, not at all insufferable device, as they could
have been; the language is florid and considered and dense, such that you
sometimes need to take a few runs at a sentence, but all that extra detail is
colourful and fun – so what if you
begin to suspect that with all the bizarre ideas and bubbling befoulments it
contains, if you dropped Sky Pirates!
from a good enough height, it would splat?
Even so, I can’t help thinking
people get a bit over-excited about it.
That’s not to denigrate the book – as must be obvious, it’s one that I
liked – but to pinch a bit of Douglas Adams, well, it’s just this book, y’know? Dave Stone hasn’t written anything as
incomprehensible as Time’s Crucible or Strange England. Sure, some of the words maybe don’t super
duper exist, but he carries them off
so well and makes it all so enjoyable that I didn’t have the nerve to question them,
or any of the typos, of which there may have been one or two. Unless that’s a gag, which it might well be. Put simply, this one knows what he’s doing.
He’s often been compared, much to
his chagrin (according to the Discontinuity Guide), with Douglas Adams and
Terry Pratchett. I can see what the
comparisons are getting at, and also why he might roll his eyes. There are many New (and some Missing)
Adventures that wear their influences on their sleeve, because after all
they’re written by lovely, well-intentioned, mostly naïve young writers. Sky
Pirates! creates worlds filled with grimy and unpleasant people a bit like
how Terry Pratchett does it, and plays havoc with physics and good manners a
little in the style of Douglas Adams, but he also has his own style. There’s an anarchic quality to it, a shaggy
dog quality to the story a little like (but more focussed than) Adams, and the
sense of humour – intrinsic to Adams and Pratchett – never veers as close to
outright satire as either of them. Sky Pirates! is a fantastical sci-fi
comedy with many funny ideas, but it isn’t half as concerned with avatars for
real world things. I love that in said
(more famous) authors, but I greatly enjoyed the absence of it here. One aspect I’ve seen gently criticised is the
book’s take on religion (it’s not a major fan), which also draws it towards the
parallel-evolution jibes of Pratchett, but I found it quite harmless and
somewhat open minded and far less This Is Like That Thing, You Know, That One
than Pratchett. In any case, I’ve read
worse takes. (Looking at you, St. Anthony’s Fire.)
Stone has a reputation (see
above, etc.) for writing very silly stuff, and while there’s plenty of that,
it’s far from the only ingredient. Take
the Sloathes: amoral shape-shifting tentacle-ish blob-ish things, they honestly
believe they’re the only really living things in the cosmos (and all other life
is “pretending to move”) and exist to gluttonously collect and consume. They look like a variety of utterly
ridiculous things and some of them talk in an outlandish and silly way. But they’re also a source of immense
creativity, and as the book goes on the other characters realise they’re much
more reflective than evil, and might actually be examples of absolute,
malleable promise, waiting for the right encouragement. The various crewmen of the Schirron Dream,
the piratical ship that inspires the title, are a bit of a random assortment
collected from the various planets of the bizarre (and therefore rather
Sloathe-like) System, but the main two – nefarious Nathan Li Shao and warrior
woman Leetha – develop considerably as the book goes on. (Their story sort of goes where you’re
expecting, but Stone refrains from rubbing it in, which is a relief.) Admittedly some of the more minor ones are much more minor, sadly including the
second-in-command Kiru. The crew also
seem to pick up new people between adventures, which stretches characterisation
a bit.
The whole “pirate” side of the
story really only gets going around halfway, which ought to be a criticism, and
yet I can’t complain about the stuff that happened before. The System, a sun surrounded by four diverse
planets and assorted planetary bits, is falling apart: Planet X, home of the
Sloathes, has thrown the natural decline into overdrive, devastating worlds and
peoples. The TARDIS is ensnared by an
ancient horror from the Time Lords’ past (oh hi, cheeky bit of mythology) and
the Doctor and Bernice are separated from Roz and Chris. The former find themselves with Leetha on the
dank space station-esque world of Sere, scarcely aware of Leetha’s quest to
save the System; the latter are trapped in a Sloathe hell on Planet X. Both situations are rife with detail and
colour: Bernice observes Sere and becomes convinced the place is about to fall
apart, while Roz lives through a bizarre drug-addiction and struggles to stay
alive amid her terrifying, ridiculous captors.
In the middle of all this, the quest to find the Eyes – one gem per
planet, which united may save the System – is suitably at the back of everybody’s
mind that it sort of recalls the quest for the Ultimate Question, so I suppose
that’s another Douglas Adams echo if you’re looking for one.
It’s the confident juggling of
silliness, richness and thought that really made it for me. While I needed a few goes to make absolute
sense of Planet X, it was completely worth it, as their bizarre and
preposterous dialogue leapt off the page.
Leetha’s world falls into chaos as she makes her way to save it, and this
is unquestionably a time of tragedy, yet Stone turns a mystic ritual to
“discover” Leetha (and so prove she is The Chosen One) into a heartbreakingly
pathetic game of Hide And Seek. (I was
giggling for ages at that bit.) Later,
when Stone gives into the perhaps inevitable impulse to revisit the ancient
horror from Time Lord history and make it the focus of the denouement, the
Doctor really comes into focus, after being written brilliantly as someone who
can fade into the background at will and be convincingly ridiculous or serious. His sheer conviction when he faces “the thing
inside”, the being behind it all, hefts more weight onto what could, at a
glance, look like a daft jaunt around some goofy planets on a weirdo spaceship. This is the Doctor at his most grave,
struggling against the innate violence of his people and himself. (Which neatly echoes the Doctor and Pryce’s discussion about murder in Original Sin, deliberately or otherwise.) Bernice shows light and shade throughout,
with perhaps more emphasis on shade: she’s utterly cynical about the Doctor at
times, as she’s got a bee in her bonnet that he’s doing one of his “stand back
and manipulate” jobs on the whole affair.
She has every reason to be suspicious: we know, as she does, that the
man quaintly pottering about the kitchen in a chef’s hat is not what he seems.
There is, I suppose, a feeling
that Chris and Roz are bundled into a subplot, as you might expect right after
they’re introduced. It’s hard to
pinpoint if this is a “good” Roz and Chris book, as they’re in such completely
alien surroundings compared with Original Sin.
However, Stone convincingly handles inter-novel continuity so it feels
like he’s at least read the one before, and the story eventually takes the
stance of putting them through the wringer to see if this is even something
they want to do. It’s meant to leave them a bit
bleary-eyed. It’s not a Roz-and-Chris-apalooza, especially on the Chris side, but nor
is it a betrayal of either of them. I
enjoyed their story.
As far as other criticisms go,
there is a sense of cutting bits and briskly accelerating the pace after
halfway, but it’s a long-ish book by New Adventures standards, so I get why the
quest to find each Eye becomes truncated: one is a deliberate and hilarious
anti-climax related after the fact by Bernice.
Again, what could be a problem (and maybe is) is tackled head on and
then smartly juggled. Along with other
bits, like the too-numerous crew, it’s not perfect. And yet reading Sky Pirates!, I never got over the sheer delight of a
fully-realised author. I’ve read some
very good books since Genesys, and discovered some fabulous authors like Paul
Cornell, Jim Mortimore and Andy Lane, but let’s face it, there’s a higher
proportion of dross. There have been
times when Sky Pirates! would seem like
the first two-eyed monkey swaggering into a one-eyed tribe.
To sum up: don’t panic. Sky
Pirates! is as fruitsome and odd as some of the other really good comedic
sci-fi novels you’ve read, including (and perhaps especially) ones that aren’t Doctor Who. It’s also good Doctor Who, and if it sometimes seems to go on a bit, take your
time. I’m still not certain I understood
every word, and I honestly don’t mind. Call
it an excuse to come back.
9/10
Unfortunately, for me it was a bit of a chore to read. 350 pages is way too long for Dave Stone's florid Terry Pratchett stylings. Even though there are a great many hilarious jokes in this book, and I loved that the seventh Doctor resumes his colourful antics from Time and the Rani (including skittering on one foot around the corne rof a corridor), there are simply too many other dreadful attempts to amuse.
ReplyDeleteIn the end I discovered that I did like most of the ideas in this novel. The sloathes are a terrific monster; the bizarre System has a cool reason for existing and for appearing as it does in the eyes and senses of humanoids; all of the zaniness and surreality have a serious grounding in the plot.
I am not sureabout the superhuman Doctor however. I have complaine din the past about this, but it has been rightly pointed out to me that even on television, the Doctor had soem superhuamn qualities. But in this book he surpasses Superman himself in the climactic confrontation. Perhaps however, which is why I say I am not sure, Dave Stone meant that the superhuman, large-as-a-solar-system other other body of the Doctor was meant to be another part of the illusions in this surreal sub-universe created by the alien.
5/10 I mark it positively because of its humour, characters and ideas; and despite its length, molasses-thick style and frequent boring bits. Averages out.